Tuesday, June 19, 2018 Game Recap and Discussion [SPOILERS]
Moderators: alietr, trainman, econgator, dhkendall
-
- Valued Contributor
- Posts: 89
- Joined: Mon Jul 27, 2015 8:32 pm
Re: Tuesday, June 19, 2018 Game Recap and Discussion [SPOILERS]
I feel if Truman had been the correct response, the clue would have read "sent a congratulatory telegram, but later told reporters..." The choice of the word "then" implies to me that the comment to reporters happened immediately after the sending of the telegram.
- opusthepenguin
- The Best Darn Penguin on the Whole JBoard
- Posts: 10319
- Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2011 2:33 pm
- Location: Shawnee, KS
- Contact:
Re: Tuesday, June 19, 2018 Game Recap and Discussion [SPOILERS]
We'll have to agree to disagree here. I see your point but I don't think the word "then" can bear that kind of weight. I think it would be deceptive for the clue to be written the way it is to describe the situation you envision. I don't think the following interpretation of the clue's language is defensible: "On November 3, 1948 he sent a congratulatory telegram, then [but not immediately after, rather after an unspecified event occurred that put that telegram in a different context, he] told reporters, 'I was just as surprised as you'". That's way too much meaning to load into the word "then". I get that you can think of Truman and get in a mental rut where you try to read the words that way. I just can't agree that this understanding represents a plain or even a fair if unlikely interpretation. Maybe if the clue had said "then later". Absent any clarification, "then" needs to mean "the next thing that happened was" or the clue is a cheat.Elijah Baley wrote: ↑Thu Jun 21, 2018 8:04 amYes, the clue makes sense in another way: Truman sees early results that show Dewey winning, in accordance with conventional wisdom. He sends a congratulatory telegram. Short time later, results show Truman won so he tells reporters, "I'm just as surprised as you."opusthepenguin wrote: ↑Wed Jun 20, 2018 9:28 pmOn November 3, 1948 he sent a congratulatory telegram, then told reporters, “I was just as surprised as you”Elijah Baley wrote: ↑Wed Jun 20, 2018 7:47 pm No argument from me. But, I'm not saying that there's nothing that would lead to Dewey; instead, nothing jumps out that points definitively to him, as Alex implied. Unless you have pretty specific knowledge - like the fact that November 3 was the day after the election - either response seems pretty reasonable.
I don't think the clue makes sense unless the telegram and the comment to reporters BOTH happened after the "surprise". Given that, Alex's comment was exactly right. Truman wouldn't be the one sending the congratulatory telegram.
-
- Watches Jeopardy! Way Too Much
- Posts: 1045
- Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2014 8:27 pm
Re: Tuesday, June 19, 2018 Game Recap and Discussion [SPOILERS]
Ok, I surrender! Anyone who read the clue as possibly pointing to Truman is obviously unfamiliar with the strict rigidity of the English language.opusthepenguin wrote: ↑Thu Jun 21, 2018 10:32 amWe'll have to agree to disagree here. I see your point but I don't think the word "then" can bear that kind of weight. I think it would be deceptive for the clue to be written the way it is to describe the situation you envision. I don't think the following interpretation of the clue's language is defensible: "On November 3, 1948 he sent a congratulatory telegram, then [but not immediately after, rather after an unspecified event occurred that put that telegram in a different context, he] told reporters, 'I was just as surprised as you'". That's way too much meaning to load into the word "then". I get that you can think of Truman and get in a mental rut where you try to read the words that way. I just can't agree that this understanding represents a plain or even a fair if unlikely interpretation. Maybe if the clue had said "then later". Absent any clarification, "then" needs to mean "the next thing that happened was" or the clue is a cheat.Elijah Baley wrote: ↑Thu Jun 21, 2018 8:04 amYes, the clue makes sense in another way: Truman sees early results that show Dewey winning, in accordance with conventional wisdom. He sends a congratulatory telegram. Short time later, results show Truman won so he tells reporters, "I'm just as surprised as you."opusthepenguin wrote: ↑Wed Jun 20, 2018 9:28 pmOn November 3, 1948 he sent a congratulatory telegram, then told reporters, “I was just as surprised as you”Elijah Baley wrote: ↑Wed Jun 20, 2018 7:47 pm No argument from me. But, I'm not saying that there's nothing that would lead to Dewey; instead, nothing jumps out that points definitively to him, as Alex implied. Unless you have pretty specific knowledge - like the fact that November 3 was the day after the election - either response seems pretty reasonable.
I don't think the clue makes sense unless the telegram and the comment to reporters BOTH happened after the "surprise". Given that, Alex's comment was exactly right. Truman wouldn't be the one sending the congratulatory telegram.
-
- Watches Jeopardy! Way Too Much
- Posts: 6030
- Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2012 10:55 pm
Re: Tuesday, June 19, 2018 Game Recap and Discussion [SPOILERS]
As I suggested in my post above, my immediate idea for the first 10 seconds was that maybe Truman sent a wire congratulating Dewey for the headline, then turned on the press with a needling remark that also established his humility in winning his own term...After :10 or so, that started to seem too elaborate for FJ...But yes, the clue can be parsed in more than one way.Elijah Baley wrote: ↑Thu Jun 21, 2018 11:40 amOk, I surrender! Anyone who read the clue as possibly pointing to Truman is obviously unfamiliar with the strict rigidity of the English language.opusthepenguin wrote: ↑Thu Jun 21, 2018 10:32 amWe'll have to agree to disagree here. I see your point but I don't think the word "then" can bear that kind of weight. I think it would be deceptive for the clue to be written the way it is to describe the situation you envision. I don't think the following interpretation of the clue's language is defensible: "On November 3, 1948 he sent a congratulatory telegram, then [but not immediately after, rather after an unspecified event occurred that put that telegram in a different context, he] told reporters, 'I was just as surprised as you'". That's way too much meaning to load into the word "then". I get that you can think of Truman and get in a mental rut where you try to read the words that way. I just can't agree that this understanding represents a plain or even a fair if unlikely interpretation. Maybe if the clue had said "then later". Absent any clarification, "then" needs to mean "the next thing that happened was" or the clue is a cheat.Elijah Baley wrote: ↑Thu Jun 21, 2018 8:04 amYes, the clue makes sense in another way: Truman sees early results that show Dewey winning, in accordance with conventional wisdom. He sends a congratulatory telegram. Short time later, results show Truman won so he tells reporters, "I'm just as surprised as you."opusthepenguin wrote: ↑Wed Jun 20, 2018 9:28 pmOn November 3, 1948 he sent a congratulatory telegram, then told reporters, “I was just as surprised as you”Elijah Baley wrote: ↑Wed Jun 20, 2018 7:47 pm No argument from me. But, I'm not saying that there's nothing that would lead to Dewey; instead, nothing jumps out that points definitively to him, as Alex implied. Unless you have pretty specific knowledge - like the fact that November 3 was the day after the election - either response seems pretty reasonable.
I don't think the clue makes sense unless the telegram and the comment to reporters BOTH happened after the "surprise". Given that, Alex's comment was exactly right. Truman wouldn't be the one sending the congratulatory telegram.
I'll add that: Maybe I thought this because the remark seems lacking in grace coming from Dewey. It's a little Clintonian maybe, a deep-state smugness??... I think of him as the little man on the wedding cake, in Alice Roosevelt's phrase, but she probably didn't mean that he was self-effacing.
- BigDaddyMatty
- Hoping not to get pruney this time
- Posts: 3300
- Joined: Wed Jan 21, 2015 11:05 am
- Location: Anderson, IN
Re: Tuesday, June 19, 2018 Game Recap and Discussion [SPOILERS]
Coryat: 30,400
43 R/3 W
DD: 3/3
FJ:
LT: Mayflower Compact (DD), Hoboken, Dakota (DD), Detroit Red Wings
Like several of you, I was initially stuck on the landlocked = no land on the perimeter of the country idea. If not for my miss of Arkansas for Arizona, there's no way I would've gotten the Dakota DD.
43 R/3 W
DD: 3/3
FJ:
LT: Mayflower Compact (DD), Hoboken, Dakota (DD), Detroit Red Wings
Like several of you, I was initially stuck on the landlocked = no land on the perimeter of the country idea. If not for my miss of Arkansas for Arizona, there's no way I would've gotten the Dakota DD.
Sprinkles are for winners.
-
- Valued Contributor
- Posts: 89
- Joined: Mon Jul 27, 2015 8:32 pm
- jeff6286
- Watches Jeopardy! Way Too Much
- Posts: 5228
- Joined: Fri Jul 01, 2011 7:34 pm
- Location: Indianapolis, IN
Re: Tuesday, June 19, 2018 Game Recap and Discussion [SPOILERS]
I tend to agree in hindsight that the usage of “then” is a decent pointer to Dewey over Truman. However, in the immediate aftermath of the clue and particularly given Alex’s reaction to the misses, I hated the clue as it seemed perfectly reasonable to give either Dewey or Truman if you have no personal knowledge of the telegram, and especially if you don’t know if November 3 was Tuesday or Wednesday.
What made me lean toward the wrong response during the thinking time was that of course the loser would always concede or congratulate the winner, that would happen in virtually every election. the thing that makes this notable is that in this case the eventual winner sent a note of congratulations, that’s why they’re asking about it! I still maintain that this logic is powerful enough to overcome the opposing logic which is mostly strengthened by the implied meaning of the word “then”, and therefore I still very much hate this choice as an FJ clue!
What made me lean toward the wrong response during the thinking time was that of course the loser would always concede or congratulate the winner, that would happen in virtually every election. the thing that makes this notable is that in this case the eventual winner sent a note of congratulations, that’s why they’re asking about it! I still maintain that this logic is powerful enough to overcome the opposing logic which is mostly strengthened by the implied meaning of the word “then”, and therefore I still very much hate this choice as an FJ clue!
- jeff6286
- Watches Jeopardy! Way Too Much
- Posts: 5228
- Joined: Fri Jul 01, 2011 7:34 pm
- Location: Indianapolis, IN
Re: Tuesday, June 19, 2018 Game Recap and Discussion [SPOILERS]
I have to say that this meta-solving advice seems way off the mark. I’ve watched more than enough Jeopardy! and I know full well that you’ve watched more than enough Jeopardy! to know that a pretty significant percentage of the time, the FJ clue points very clearly toward an obvious answer and most of the time that answer is the right one.seaborgium wrote: ↑Wed Jun 20, 2018 8:41 pm"I was just as surprised as you" seems to point definitively to Dewey. It sounds like a commiseration: "Boy oh boy, guys, we both failed pretty hard, huh?"Elijah Baley wrote: ↑Wed Jun 20, 2018 7:47 pmNo argument from me. But, I'm not saying that there's nothing that would lead to Dewey; instead, nothing jumps out that points definitively to him, as Alex implied. Unless you have pretty specific knowledge - like the fact that November 3 was the day after the election - either response seems pretty reasonable.Stanislaus Jacob wrote: ↑Wed Jun 20, 2018 6:17 pmI wouldn't say that this was the greatest clue of all time, but I would defend it. Truman's feisty personality is fairly well-known, and he does not seem like the type who would concede prematurely. And the famous picture of him mockingly holding up the Tribune does not match the idea that he would admit to reporters, "I was just as surprised as you." And finally, the wording seems to imply that the telegram was followed immediately by the comment, not that there was a gap of several hours as the situation gradually reversed.Elijah Baley wrote: ↑Wed Jun 20, 2018 2:58 pm
To me, this question was a toss-up between Dewey and Truman. Since it was widely expected that Dewey would win, it seems very possible that Truman could have sent a telegram congratulating Dewey on his "win," only to find out later that the results were in his favor. As it turns out, the election was on November 2, 1948, so this scenario is pretty unlikely for Truman sending a telegram on November 3 - although it could have been just after midnight. But, there's no way that they should expect that any contestant would know the exact date of the election.
So, Alex's "explanation" that only one person would get a congratulatory telegram in the context of an election sounds reasonable, but it's really just lazy thinking.
I can see your point, but I think there was enough to lead someone to the correct response.
You could also meta-solve this FJ by thinking, "They gave an exact date which corresponds to the first election after WWII. Given that, Truman's a little too on-the-nose a response; it's probably the guy he beat."
Saying “oh the obvious response is too on-the-nose, it must be something harder or more obscure”, down that path lies madness, and TPH!
- opusthepenguin
- The Best Darn Penguin on the Whole JBoard
- Posts: 10319
- Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2011 2:33 pm
- Location: Shawnee, KS
- Contact:
Re: Tuesday, June 19, 2018 Game Recap and Discussion [SPOILERS]
I think that's an excellent point. I can easily see how one could get on the Truman train and not find a way or a need to get off it before the music ended.jeff6286 wrote: ↑Sun Jun 24, 2018 2:45 am I tend to agree in hindsight that the usage of “then” is a decent pointer to Dewey over Truman. However, in the immediate aftermath of the clue and particularly given Alex’s reaction to the misses, I hated the clue as it seemed perfectly reasonable to give either Dewey or Truman if you have no personal knowledge of the telegram, and especially if you don’t know if November 3 was Tuesday or Wednesday.
What made me lean toward the wrong response during the thinking time was that of course the loser would always concede or congratulate the winner, that would happen in virtually every election. the thing that makes this notable is that in this case the eventual winner sent a note of congratulations, that’s why they’re asking about it! I still maintain that this logic is powerful enough to overcome the opposing logic which is mostly strengthened by the implied meaning of the word “then”, and therefore I still very much hate this choice as an FJ clue!
On the other hand, the clue is currently polling at 73%. It can't be THAT misleading.
-
- Watches Jeopardy! Way Too Much
- Posts: 6030
- Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2012 10:55 pm
Re: Tuesday, June 19, 2018 Game Recap and Discussion [SPOILERS]
He sent the telegram the next day, after 11 AM, when it was clear he had lost-1stlvlthinker wrote: ↑Mon Jun 25, 2018 12:32 pm Wait, if everyone thought Dewey was the winner, why would Dewey be sending the telegram?
https://www.trumanlibrary.org/whistlest ... tretch.htm
In fact, the Chicago Tribune headline was wrong and premature, as was quickly realized by the editors when they changed it for the second edition-
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nati ... story.html